I think the title speaks for itself. If you’re an adult you know this to be true and life today is certainly not as black and white as in the days of “Ozzie and Harriet.” With that being said, I’d like to take this space and discuss something that has been occupying a lot of my time: fighting for fairness in the tobacco industry.
If you are not a resident of New York State or obsessed with tobacco legislation like myself and my colleagues, you may not know that here in the Empire State we have a problem. (Well it’s more like we have a problem that is creating more problems by the name of David Paterson and his so-called ideas to close the budget gap.) According to the most recent figures we have a $9.2 billion deficit for FY2010 and our “governor” — I use that title in quotation because not only does he refuse to lead, but when he attempts to try he fails MISERABLY — thinks that there are certain items that should be taxed in order to make up the missing money the state needs to operate.
First and foremost, I am all for taxing sugary drinks, soda, fatty foods, etc. : I know the argument is that lower income neighbourhoods will suffer, but not if this is done correctly. I live in Central Harlem and while my area is beautiful and I love my neighbours, we obviously don’t have the same cash-flow as someone living on 72nd and Fifth. I can vouch that places like Harlem and Washington Heights are riddled with greasy Chinese take out spots, pizza places, and thirty thousand types of fried chicken restaurants, but we do lack access to proper produce in our grocery stores and bodegas. It’s not that we always don’t know what to eat but it’s the ability to procure fresh fruit and vegetables that is the problem, and so with this fat & sugar tax there needs to be a concerted effort to give of the markets above 96th St the ability to sell produce that is edible. There are way too many obese and morbidly obese people in this country (and this state) and the battle starts at home.
Now onto the heart of my argument: the proposed tobacco tax. Here in New York we have the highest taxes on tobacco products in the Union along with California. At 46% when you purchase a cigar or pack of cigarettes literally half of what you pay goes to the government. Gov. Paterson thinks that raising the tax to 90% is going to solve New York’s problems because the guy who weighs 500lbs is worried about paying more than $2.00 for a 20 oz Pepsi and over $3.99 for a jumbo bag of Doritos. I hate to say it, but if smokers and tobacconists alike do not unite and remain strong and badger elected officials with phone calls/faxes/e-mails/letters providing lucid arguments then all of your favourite B&Ms will be forced to close their doors. Aside from losing the ability as an adult to freely walk into an establishment and enjoy a fine cigar, think about the hundreds of years and tradition — often family owned and operated –that will be lost along with jobs of hardworking tobacconists who not only love their craft, but have become a part of your life as your friend.
The silliest part of this whole situation is that these elected officials are not businessmen. They have no concept of the economic ramifications that exist if their tax increase makes us close our doors. Tobacco is historically a cash crop and will always be that in one form or another, and it creates revenue for the government today as it did for the monarchies of Old Europe centuries ago. If New York is running around and complaining about budget deficits could you imagine what would happen if the State received NOTHING from the sale of tobacco? We already went the prohibition route with alcohol and that backfired in a plethora of ways, but government officials don’t seem to realize that making the same mistake twice is ludicrous. This is not algebra class, folks: a negative multiplied by a negative does NOT equal a positive.
All anger and frustration aside, there are things that should be done to create more revenue and have the government leave tobacco alone. In a discussion with a friend this morning who was complaining about our new licenses plates (which are mandatory), he not only mentioned he didn’t like the colours/design, but how each car must have these plates within two years. News flash: $25 multiplied by the millions of cars registered here in New York will create billions of dollars in state revenue. In addition to the license plates and the so-called “fat tax,” is there really any harm being done to tax those who earn a substantial income at a higher rate? Taxing the rich would create a lot of windfall dollars that are ultimately necessary would by no means put that big of a dent in the life of the opulent.
The government is too big. Too many cooks in the kitchen and that costs money, so why not reduce the size of the government to reduce spending? To be perfectly honest only three real politicians here have the power, so why not weed out what is unnecessary, such as agencies funded by the government that could be consolidated with their counterparts? On an even more practical level let’s reform the budgetary process in general because all of the nonsense that goes into creating and attempting to ratify a budget often costs millions of dollars, and much of that time is spent with officials twiddling their fat thumbs.
I’m sure you all have the same feelings I do: no more taxes, no more fees, and leave tobacco alone. In the past two years between City and State we’ve had four new taxes levied on us here for tobacco and that’s just ridiculous. Whether you are a tobacco enthusiast, tobacconist, shop owner, or occasional lover of cigars you need to exercise your rights and make your voice be heard. I have seen instances before where collective efforts, calculated arguments, and large numbers are not ignored and proposed tobacco legislation is defeated. If you are unsure of where to go, please talk to your local tobacconist who can provide you with form letters where all you have to do is sign your name in support of this cause. If any of you want to contact me I have letters, names, and addresses of those you can write to, e-mail, call, or fax and I would be happy to send you what you need to stand up and let your voice be heard
“I think myself that we have more machinery of government than is necessary, too many parasites living on the labor of the industrious.” — Thomas Jefferson